Legally Organizing Your Business - Continuation Page
Limited
Liability Companies
Limited Liability Companies (LLCs) are the newest form of organization in the
USA. Picture them as a cross between a corporation and a partnership. They offer
all the flexibility of a sole proprietorship or general partnership combined
with the limited liability of a corporation. Because they are new and so
flexible, the IRS has no idea how to classify these entities. So the IRS
developed "Check the Box" regulations, which permit you to pick the
best tax status for you. Better yet, you can change the tax status periodically
without having to form a new entity or get new tax ID numbers - simply
"check the box" again on the appropriate IRS form.
While LLCs appear to have all the advantages, there is one apparent
disadvantage. When a business has multiple owners, disputes can be difficult to
resolve. LLCs's are not required to hold any meetings or keep minutes, or even
have articles of organization (although this is a very good idea). So in the
case of a business dispute between owners (called "members") there may
not be sufficient documentation to guide the members (or their lawyers) on how
to amicably resolve the dispute.
Some business owners have organized themselves as non-profit corporations.
Note that just because a Secretary of State grants non-profit status (which is
very easy to get), does NOT mean that the IRS (and state department of taxation)
will do so also. In fact, the IRS approval of tax-exempt status is very
cumbersome and expensive to obtain. There are also several types of non-profits.
Some are simply tax exempt, others can offer charitable write-offs to donors,
and some have one of several special non-profit status set forth in the tax
code. Few small businesses are organized as tax exempt entities. You should
consult your CPA or lawyer before pursuing this course of organization to
discuss the pros and cons.
Occasionally, businesses are operated under the form of a trust or
foundation. This is quite rare. When trusts or foundations are involved, usually
the business is organized as a corporation of LLC, with the trust or foundation
owning the shares or membership. Some business owners have formed off-shore
trusts and foundations to own their companies.
International Charters
You should consider offshore entities extremely carefully, for two
reasons. First, the IRS has very strict rules regarding reporting of offshore
activities, and the IRS is even more brutal in this area than other areas. Also,
some of the foreign forms of organization have no corresponding entity form in
the US. Therefore, legal scholars are uncertain how the courts may treat them in
most cases. Finally, offshore entities will be subject to the laws and integrity
of the foreign jurisdictions and people who administer them. Differences in
culture, political stability and legal structure as well as language
misunderstandings can affect you in unintended ways. If this is an area of
concern for you or you are considering forming an offshore entity, we suggest
that you consult a specialist in this area.
Changing Organizational Forms
If you own a small business over a long period of time, there will be several
occasions to change the form of business. There is no one perfect form of
organization that will serve you for a lifetime. The tax laws and corporate law
is constantly changing. At various times, corporate tax rates were lower than
personal tax rates; at other times the reverse was true. Also, you may want to
choose an organizational form that does not limit losses in the early startup
years. Later you may want to use a "S" corporation to "suck
cash" from the business. Finally, as you mellow into a "fat cat"
owner, the "C" corporation will enable you to bury large portions of
unused profits into various fringe benefits plans. You should consult your CPA
or lawyer periodically to make sure you are still using the instrument that
makes the most sense for where you are now and where you want to go over the
next few years.